Twilight of the Gods: War in the Western Pacific, 1944-1945: 3 Pocketbok – 27 Juli 2021
Förbättra ditt köp
Köps ofta tillsammans
[A] richly rewarding history.-- "Kirkus Reviews (starred review)"
I've been a fan of Ian W. Toll's since his first book, Six Frigates, but this concluding volume of his Pacific War Trilogy has taken him to another level altogether. Twilight of the Gods grabs you from the beginning and doesn't let go until the very end--an epic masterpiece of military history.--Nathaniel Philbrick, National Book Award-winning author of In the Heart of the Sea and finalist for the Pulitzer Prize
Toll weaves a brilliant final act depicting one of humanity's epic tragedies. This book and its predecessors set a high bar for historians of the Pacific War.--Jonathan W. Jordan "Wall Street Journal"
Toll's expertly navigated narrative includes a number of new insights...It is exhaustive and authoritative and it shows the Navy in World War II as it really was, warts and all.--Mark Perry "New York Times Book Review"
Using meticulous research, including previously untapped primary sources, and a brisk narrative that combines strategic, operational, and personal perspectives, [Toll] presents a very balanced look at the critical decisions and actions on both sides that concluded the war.--Jerry Lenaburg "New York Journal of Books"
Written with flair and chock-full of stories both familiar and fresh, this monumental history fires on all cylinders. WWII aficionados will be enthralled.-- "Publishers Weekly (starred review)"
In his masterly narrative, Ian W. Toll brings clarity and a stinging immediacy to America's long, bitter climb up the island ladder that led to Japan. With deft, incisive character sketches, Toll summons the leaders back to contentious life: arguing about what to do, making mistakes, bringing triumph out of disaster--and sometimes the reverse. This is maritime history at its best and most accessible.--Richard Snow
No one has told the story of World War II in the Pacific, from beginning to bitter end, better than Ian W. Toll. This final volume concludes a brilliant trilogy. Elegant and supremely readable--don't miss the finest military history of 2020.--Alex Kershaw, New York Times best-selling author of The First Wave and Avenue of Spies
Praise for the Pacific War Trilogy:
THE CONQUERING TIDE
"A gripping narrative of the central Pacific campaign...Toll is strong on the operational details of battle, but he is no less skilled at presenting something that is frequently missing from military histories, a well-rounded depiction of the home front on both sides."
- Walter R. Borneman, New York Times Book Review
"A beautiful blend of history and prose and proves again Mr. Toll's mastery of the naval-war narrative."
- Jonathan W. Jordan, Wall Street Journal
"A lucid and learned exposition of the grand chess match between high commanders in the middle years of the Pacific War, vividly evoking the grit and gristle of its many horrors and triumphs. Ian W. Toll is a superb historian whose writing appeals to both the head and the heart."
- James D. Hornfischer, author of The Fleet at Flood Tide
"Vivid, fast moving and highly readable."
- Ronald Spector, Wall Street Journal
- Utgivare : W. W. Norton & Company (27 Juli 2021)
- Språk : Engelska
- Pocketbok : 976 sidor
- ISBN-10 : 0393868303
- ISBN-13 : 978-0393868302
Populäraste recensionerna från andra länder
It is a history that is very much focused on the United States effort against the Japanese. For a broader view of the last year of the war then Nemesis: The Battle for Japan, 1944-45 by Max Hastings is worth buying and reading in addition to Ian Toll's Twilight of the Gods.
Ian Toll starts with the meeting of President Roosevelt with General MacArthur and Admiral Nimitz in Hawaii. It deals with the battle for Peleliu, Leyte Gulf and Admiral Kurita, the strategic bombing of Japan, Iwo Jima, Manila, Okinawa, and, of course, the bombs on Hiroshima & Nagasaki, the entry of the Soviet Union into the war, and the Japanese surrender of 15 August 1945. There are bits on what happened on the Japanese and United States home fronts both during and after the war.
Although he does not always clearly express his opinions, possibly preferring to keep them close to his chest, Ian Toll touches on all the main controversies of the later stages of the Pacific War: (i) Were islands invaded that could have been bypassed - Peleliu, Iwo Jima, the Philippines. (ii) Why did Admiral Kurita not bash the Americans harder in Leyte Gulf. (iii) Admiral Halsey's performance as commander of the Third Fleet. (iv) The Bombs and, in particular, that second bomb on Nagasaki.
As hinted at above, I think that there is a much broader picture to the Pacific War than Ian Toll's trilogy covers, and then I can recommend John Toland, James Hornfischer, and Richard Frank ... in addition to Ian Toll.
This closing volume of the trilogy opens with the July 1944 Hawaiian Conference between Roosevelt, Nimitz, Macarthur and Leahy, which finally settled the question of Allied Strategy in favour of Macarthur's desire to liberate the Philippines. This was to be coupled with the cancellation of Operation Causeway [the invasion of Formosa] and its replacement by an amphibious drive towards the Japanese Home Islands, via Iwo Jima and Okinawa. The volume then describes the resultant campaigns, including the Battle of Leyte Gulf and the rise of the Kamikazes, before addressing the dropping of the atomic bombs, the Japanese surrender and its aftermath, including the early days of the US occupation of Japan. Although the book's perspective is, understandably, focused mostly on American operations, Toll finds space to describe the contribution of the British Far East Fleet in the final months of the fighting. Like its two predecessor volumes, this part of the trilogy is slightly let down by barely adequate mapping although, yet again, the photographs were, to me, new and interesting.
The book covers the period from the summer of 1944 to August/September 1945 in almost 800 compelling pages.
I liken the book to a bobsleigh ride on the Cresta run; once you are on you cannot get off, hurtling down at increasing speed to a devastating climax.
I have read a great many books about the war in the Pacific and Burma and believe me it was brutal. I have read the ‘Marines in World War II Commemorative Series’ booklets which recount the exploits of the US Marine Corps as they fought from island to island (I was truly fortunate to receive the copies courtesy of the USMC). I am thus fully seized of the ferocity of the action in the jungles of countless islands scattered across the Pacific Ocean. Toll’s books emphasise the centrality of the naval war to victory, simply put if the USN did not wrest command of the Pacific from the IJN then victory over Japan may have eluded the Allies (the British Pacific Fleet played a supporting role after the defeat of Germany).
Toll covers all aspects of the conflict from the American and Japanese home fronts to the highest offices of Government. The extent of the inter-service conflicts among the America and Japanese armed forces is quite extraordinary; Douglas MacArthur’s long running dispute with the senior officers of the USN for example. The rivalry between the Japanese army and navy was almost certainly responsible for speeding their defeat.
As we know them the kamikaze were a terrifying phenomenon, but I did not fully grasp just how serious a threat they were to US warships. And while most Japanese pilots did volunteer to dash themselves and their aircraft again US warships a significant number were resentful and some contrived to abort their mission.
Toll reminds the reader the USN was fighting everyday from the attack on Pearl Harbor to the surrender in August 1945 while the US Army and USAAF (sic) had a slow start.
Toll does also cover the ground war in significant detail.
The author goes into considerable detail about the deliberation of the Japanese government in the aftermath of the raids upon Hiroshima and Nagasaki. Incredibly some senior figures wanted to continue the war clinging desperately to the banzai ethos.
I cannot recommend this book and its two companion volumes too highly. I suspect this three-volume study will become the seminal work about the naval war in the Pacific.
Next there are over 100 pages alone on the Battles of Leyte Gulf, plus the US landings on Leyte. It's incredibly detailed, as was the aftermath, and it's importance overall on the outcome of the war in the Pacific. There was more political stuff afterwards, until the reconquest of the Philippines, with the emphasis on Luzon and retaking the capital Manilla.
I really liked the next part about the sinking of the Yamato, then just one chapter on the landings and battle for Iwa Jima. There was a lot on the battle for Okinawa and subsequent landings, the bombing of Tokyo and most of Japan's cities, then the book goes out with a bang with the chapter on the dropping of the atom bombs on Hiroshima and Nagasaki.
Overall a great end to one of the greatest trilogies on World War 2 in the Pacific ever written.